Review topics: ["color","feel","size","issues","fit","look","style","shoes","strap","fabric","comfort","mary janes","padding","quality","material","support","comfy","weight","stretch","rothy","band","feet","pair","toe","wear","cushion","flats","footbed","cruise","insole"].
Reviews
Most comfortable Rothy's
"I ordered these in the beautiful pinky-red color after trying out all the various Rothy models in-store. The Cruisers are, by far, the most comfortable to me. The Cruiser Mary Jane, in particular, is so comfortable, roomy, and super cute! The strap at the top is great and doesn't rub on my foot. I'm thinking about purchasing another pair for a friend who struggles with a high instep."
— Idalia M. (5/5)
Love the cherry cat!
"First time trying Rothy’s - I found them online and liked the look of the Cruiser Mary Jane. They didn’t disappoint. The revelvet material is so soft and I find them to be very comfortable- I took a short walk the first time I wore them and had no issues. I love that they are made from recycled materials! I wear 7.5 or 8 in most shoes and an 8 works well for me in these due to my wide feet."
— CATHERINE O. (5/5)
Perfect comfy shoes for all day wear.
"Love the Cruiser Mary Jane! I am usually between a size 5.5 and 6, and I ordered a size 6. The fit is great, and the Mary Jane strap helps keep them secure on my feet. If they were a regular loafer style without the strap, they would likely slip off. For comparison, I wear a size 5.5 in other Rothy's loafers and they fit perfectly."
— jessica m. (5/5)
Great looking shoes but inconsistent sizing
"My other Mary Jane’s fit perfectly in a 7.5 but these are too big. I love Rothy’s but hate the inconsistent sizing. I wear a 7.5 in the point, a 6 in the clog, a 7 in the RSO sneakers, 6.5 in these new sneakers… so tough to know what size to get."
— Carissa S. (4/5)
Great Work Shoe
"I love these shoes. Sometimes I need to look at my feet to make sure I didn’t leave the house in slippers!! I normally wear a 7 1/2 and they are comfortable but I think I will order a 1/2 size up for my next pair because my feet are wide."
— Rena L. (5/5)
Velvet luxury!
"These ReVelvet Green Mary Jane’s are a quiet little luxury — the velvet catches the light like it costs twice what it does, and the fit is so soft it feels like being wrapped in something expensive. The green is rich without being loud, and the whole shoe has that “I dressed up without trying” energy. If you want shoes that make you feel put-together on autopilot, these are them."
— Amy C. (5/5)
Horrible fit
"I bought my regular size and the material is so loose they feel dangerous to walk in. The length is great. I even added another footbed from another shoe to take up some room and then they just looked awful. I can’t return them as I bought them on a $10 off sale- no returns. I was shocked. I live the color but this was a huge mistake. Very disgusted."
— Barbara T. (1/5)
Comfortable & Stylish
"Love, love, love these shoes! These shoes are so comfortable. My feet do not sweat at all and I could walk all day in them. I do recommend sizing up a half to a whole size as my normal size is a bit snug in the length. I would have exchanged but the color sold out fast!"
— Sara H. (5/5)
Comfort as always but loose strap
"As always, these Roth, these are super comfortable, but what I noticed after the first or second, where is that? The strap feels loose. Not sure if it’s a fluke on this pair, but my feet don’t necessarily feel secure."
— Kim H. (4/5)
So comfortable!
"Took these shoes to Europe and loved the pop of color it added to my outfits. Easy to pack, comfortable to walk in all day, and stylish. Love them! - I sized .5 up but that’s personal preference, I don’t think it’s truly necessary"
— ALEXANDRA T. (5/5)